Company Testimonials

"Great stay! "

"We loved staying at the Castle! The room was nice, the breakfasts were excellent, the decor was lovely and the pool was wonderful!"

"We stayed in the Lighthouse Suite this past weekend which is a special thing in itself. It was a very nice stay. We loved the pool, use of bicycles, pool table. Just a very special place on a very unique and quiet island! "

"Everything was AMAZING! Food, room, bikes, Warner—we had a wonderful time."

"Clean and quiet with basic amenities similar to that of a hotel. Simple breakfast served in the morning with choice of eggs, bagels, cereal, etc. "

"We have at the Castle many times and have enjoyed each visit. It is a unique island experience - made all the better by the folks working there!"

"I love staying at The Castle! I enjoy the quite, peaceful atmosphere and the adorable house that makes me feel I am staying art Grandma’s house! "

"Would definitely stay again. "

"We were met with a friendly greeting, easy check-in, clean room and it was overall a wonderful stay. We'll be back!"

"The most beautiful B&B with the kindest staff. Felt like we got more than our money’s worth staying here! Webb’s room was quirky, homey, and absolutely lovely. Can’t wait for our next visit! "

"Great location, hospitality, accommodations, and food. Warner made us feel welcomed immediately upon arrival and our room was lovely and we look forward to enjoying Janes room again. "

"Excellent with minor issues."

"Excellent stay. Innkeeper was so professional and welcoming. Rooms clean and ready. Wonderful breakfasts, cleaning services and other amenities."

"How can a place named The Castle on Silver Lake not be magical? The setting overlooking Silver Lake Harbor and the architecture with its intricate woodworking throughout the interior was enough to entice us to come more than 20 years ago. However, it’s the folks that run it and the other guests, like us, that keep us returning. Celebrating our 50th anniversary was a milestone and The Castle was the perfect setting. Martha and her delicious breakfasts, always served with a beautiful smile, made our stay even better. Making new friends at the breakfast table is something you can’t do at a hotel. This was our 4th stay - and always in the Lighthouse Suite. While the Castle is showing some wear, it’s still comfortable and homey. Whether you want to stay a night on Ocracoke or a full week like we do, you won’t be disappointed with the magic of The Castle. "

"Lovely stay! Room was clean and cozy!"

"We had a wonderful time at the Castle on Ocracoke island."

"Warner made this stay fantastic. The breakfast crew was wonderful as well. Just an incredible week. Thanks!! JPW "

"Wonderful facility. Staff is just great! Although an historic building, it is extremely well maintained. Our room and head were spotless. Breakfast by Martha was over the top. We had to make a change to our stay and both Kim and Amanda who handle bookings were so very helpful. We will be back! Noteworthy details: They have a floating dock with space available for guest boats."

"Our stay was exceptional. We were only there one night while traveling from Nags Head to Wilmington. The building has historic and eccentric charm. We walked to the nearby lighthouse and Springers Point. Breakfast was excellent. Noteworthy details: I recommend learning about Samuel Jones, the guy that built the place. You can also visit his gravesite at Springer's Point where he was buried next to his horse."

"Warner was so kind and willing to help. Breakfasts were delicious. Room was so comfortable with delightful ambiance and tasteful furnishings. "

"Great location, really nice breakfast, multiple nice touches - snacks, coffee, water available 24/7. Ample parking. Quiet. Comfortable common spaces. Enjoyed using the pool, pool table and bicycles. "

"Such a cool building with so many perks! This is our new favorite spot in Ocracoke!"

"Pleasant accommodation, relatively clean. convenient to the small island of Ocracoke. Breakfast was good, coffee bar could definitely use a modern upgrade in that most people like higher quality, coffee ingredients and those who enjoy generally would prefer real half-and-half or cream for their coffee. Yes, you can say I’m a coffee snob. The pool and pool area were clean and lovely. Unfortunately, during a severe heat wave, they left the pool heater on in error. For peaks it’s a good value. Check-in is exceptionally easy. Loved all of the seating areas within screened porches. The only staff we met was kind and courteous."

"Still mostly like this place but the breakfast wasn’t as good as last year and pool towels were not kept stocked."